News & Press | Riverine Plains

Carbon projects Part 3: Is a carbon project the right fit for me?

Written by Sayra Samudio | Nov 20, 2026, 1:45:07 AM

Low Carbon Landscapes guide – part 3

Key messages

  • Deciding whether to commit to a carbon project requires looking beyond potential returns, considering land control, succession plans, cash flow, workload and appetite for risk.

  • The right approach will look different for every farm, with cropping, livestock and mixed farming systems each offering different opportunities and considerations.

  • A carbon project isn't the only way to gain value from practice changes, with productivity improvements, supply chain programs and biodiversity options worth considering if a project isn't the right fit.

In Parts 1 & 2, we looked at the how and why of carbon projects and their feasibility (whether a carbon project could work on your farm and pay its way). While a feasibility gives you the evidence, the final call is yours, and the decision depends on things no map or model can tell you.

Part 3 of our carbon farming guide explores the issues that can lead to a final decision.

Making the final decision: the short version

A project can look great on paper and still be wrong for your farm. Before committing, we recommend working through a few honest questions about control of the land, your plans, your cash flow and your appetite for risk. If the answers line up, a carbon project may be worth exploring. If they don't, that's a perfectly good outcome too, and there are other ways to get value from the same practice changes.

From assessment to decision

The feasibility: could it work?

A carbon project feasibility is an evidence-based assessment that someone (i.e. a third party) can help you with. A feasibility looks at whether the land qualifies, if there is room to build carbon and if the likely credits outweigh the costs (see Part 2 in this series).

In our Low Carbon Landscapes project, the Environmental Farm Assessment (EFA) was the starting point for this.

But is a carbon project right for me?

This is a question only you can answer.

Does a project fit your goals, your succession plans, your cash flow, your workload and how much risk you're comfortable with?

Think back to the pre-purchase inspection on a second-hand header. The inspection tells you whether the machine is sound and the price is fair. Whether you should buy it this year, with your money and your plans, is up to you.

A carbon project lasts at least 25 years and the obligations stay with the land. The right project should support where your business is heading, not pull it in a different direction.

As Ed Scott from Field Systems put it at our first Low carbon landscapes project meeting, working through these questions is worthwhile whether or not you go ahead, because it makes you think about what you want your land to look like over the next 25 years.

The decision path

A decision path helps to arrive at the final yes/no decision by working down the questions. Each "no" isn't a dead end as it can point you to a more useful next step.

Questions to talk through

The following questions expand on the decision path. You don't need every answer straight away, but if several are a clear "no" or "I'm not sure", it's a sign to slow down and talk it through.

Control of the land

  • Do I own the land, or have long-term control of it?

  • Will others with an interest, such as my bank, co-owners or family members, agree?

Your plans

  • Is there a new practice I'd want to adopt anyway, because it would improve productivity or resilience?

  • Does a 25 or 100-year commitment fit my succession plans? Have I talked it through with my family?

  • Could I need this land for something else in future, such as cropping, a new enterprise or selling part of the farm?

Money and risk

  • Can my cash flow handle costs that come years before any credits?

  • Am I comfortable with the risk that a drought, fire or poor season could slow or reverse carbon gains?

  • Would a carbon project affect my buyers, or programs I'm already part of (such as a processor's sustainability program)?

Running it

  • Can I keep records of how the land is managed, now and into the future?

  • Do I have the time to manage a project, or would I rather work with a service provider?

What it can look like on different farms

Every farm is different, but here's how the options tend to look by farm type. The activities listed are examples of eligible practices under the ACCU Scheme's soil carbon method.

Cropping farms

  • Possible practices: retaining stubble, reducing tillage, adding legumes or cover crops, liming acid soils or applying gypsum, or converting some paddocks to permanent pasture.

  • Things to weigh up: cropping systems generally build soil carbon more slowly than pastures, so credits may be modest. Supply chain programs, such as Cargill SustainConnect for canola, may be an easier first step.

  • Trees: non-arable corners, creek lines or poorer areas could suit an environmental planting.

Livestock farms

  • Possible practices: changing stocking rates or how long and how hard paddocks are grazed, renovating pastures, or fixing nutrient deficiencies.

  • Things to weigh up: grazing country often has good potential, especially in higher-rainfall areas. But if your paddocks are already well managed, there may be less room to improve. Permanently removing all livestock isn't an eligible way to build soil carbon.

  • Trees: shelterbelts can also benefit stock welfare, especially at lambing and calving.

Mixed farms

  • Possible practices: longer pasture phases in the rotation, adding legumes, changing grazing management, or liming.

  • Things to weigh up: mixed farms have the most flexibility. Different parts of the farm can be managed and measured separately, so you might focus a project on the areas with the best potential and leave others out.

  • Trees: plantings can fit around the rotation on areas that don't pull their weight in production.

If the answer is "not right now"

That's a perfectly good outcome. Many farms will find that a carbon project doesn't stack up today. You can still:

  • Focus the practice change on productivity. Many of the same practices, such as better grazing management, legumes or fixing soil constraints, can pay off through yield, feed and resilience, without the cost of a carbon project.

  • Look at supply chain programs, which usually involve shorter commitments (see Part 1).

  • Explore biodiversity options for native vegetation on your farm (see Part 2).

  • Keep your data. Your feasibility results and farm records will be useful if the rules, prices or your circumstances change.

  • Think about timing. A carbon project can only credit new practices. If you might want a project in the next few years, get advice before changing or adopting significant practice change, because a change you make now may not count later.

If the answer is "worth exploring", carefully choose who to work with

Most farmers work with a carbon service provider or project developer for at least part of the process. Before you sign anything, Local Land Services suggests asking:

  • Ownership: Who will be the legal owner of the project, me or the provider? Can I still sell my land?

  • Costs and income: How will costs and credits be shared? What's included, and are there extra charges for audits or sampling? What happens if the project underperforms?

  • Services: Who handles project management, audits and compliance? What happens if I want to end the arrangement?

  • Track record: Are they a signatory to the Carbon Market Institute Code of Conduct? Do they hold an Australian Financial Services Licence? Can they connect me with other landholders they've worked with?

  • Your farm: How will they estimate your carbon potential, and will they visit the property? Will the project be tailored to your farm and your goals?

  • Legal: Do I need my bank's approval? Can I exit early, and what would it cost? Should I get independent legal and financial advice first? (The answer is yes.)

See the full Local Land Services checklist Questions to ask a carbon service provider. Local Land Services also has Natural Capital Advisors who can help you think it through.

What's next?

If a carbon project looks worth exploring, the next step is understanding the path from here to a registered project, and what happens at each stage. That's the topic of Part 4: Pathway guide. Coming soon!

Questions? Contact Kate Coffey, Head of Farmer Engagement at kate@riverineplains.org.au

This guide provides general information only and is not financial or legal advice. Always seek independent advice for your situation.

Acknowledgement

This project is proudly funded by the NSW Government through a Low Carbon Landscapes grant, delivered under the Primary Industries Productivity and Abatement Program within the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water.