Carbon projects Part 2: what do we mean by feasibility?
This guide explains what carbon project feasibility means, what it looks at, and where you can get one.
Low Carbon Landscapes guide – part 2
Key messages
A feasibility assessment determines whether a carbon project could realistically work on your farm, considering land eligibility, carbon storage potential, management changes and likely costs and returns.
Carbon potential and project feasibility are not the same thing, as factors such as soil type, rainfall, farm size, existing carbon levels and project costs all influence whether a project stacks up.
An early feasibility assessment can provide valuable farm information without committing to a carbon project, helping identify suitable areas, guide soil sampling and inform future land management decisions.
In Part 1 of our Carbon projects Guide, we covered what a carbon project is, how carbon market works and the commitment required.
In part 2, we take a look at the next step in the process — determining the feasibility of a carbon project on your farm (i.e. could it actually work?). We define what feasibility really means, what it looks at, and where you can get an assessment done.
Feasibility - the short version
A feasibility assessment is an early check on whether a carbon project could realistically work on your farm, and whether it's worth taking a closer look. It's not a commitment, and a good one will tell you just as clearly if the answer is "no".
Think of it like a pre-purchase inspection on a second-hand header: you're not buying anything yet, but you find out whether it's worth your time and money before you go further.
Potential vs feasibility: they're not the same thing
These two words come up a lot, and they mean different things.
Potential: how much carbon could your land store?
As plants grow, they take carbon dioxide from the air. Some of that carbon is stored in your soil, as organic matter from roots, stubble and manure, and some in trees, in their trunks, branches and roots.
Your land's potential is how much more carbon it could realistically store than it does now. That depends mostly on things you can't change, like soil type, rainfall and how much carbon is already there. Management is the lever you can pull.
Feasibility: could it actually work, and would it pay?
Feasibility takes that potential and asks the practical questions. For example, does the land qualify?; what would need to change?; what would it cost and what could it earn?
A project that stores plenty of carbon but would mean planting trees on your most productive country, or costs more to run than it earns, isn't feasible, however good the potential looks on a map.
As Sam Duncan from GXLab put it at the first meeting of the Low Carbon Landscapes project, someone who is six foot five with long legs might have the potential to be a great marathon runner, but if they don't have the time or resources to train, running a marathon isn't feasible.
A farm can have carbon potential and still not be a good fit for a carbon project.
What does a feasibility assessment look at?
There's a lot of noise and sales talk around carbon, and plenty of farmers are rightly sceptical. A good feasibility assessment cuts through that. It answers five practical questions about your farm, and it should be just as willing to tell you "no" as "yes".
Note: the rules and examples below specifically relate to projects under the Australian Government's ACCU Scheme — the main carbon scheme for farms in Australia and the focus of our project. Other programs, such as supply chain or international voluntary schemes, ask the same five questions but have their own eligibility rules.
What kind of project are we actually talking about?
A "carbon project" isn't just one thing.
The two main carbon project options for farms in our region work very differently; one looks at building soil carbon while you keep farming, while the other involves planting native trees on part of the farm (environmental plantings). There are also different programs through which to run them, each with their own rules, costs and length of commitment.
Why it matters: you can't judge whether something makes sense until you know exactly what's being proposed.
Does my land qualify?
Not all land is eligible.
Under the ACCU Scheme, a soil carbon project needs land used for cropping or grazing, with at least 30 cm of soil that can be sampled. An environmental planting needs an area that has been clear of trees (forest cover) for at least five years, so existing shelterbelts or bush can't be counted, and must cover at least 0.2 hectares. Soil carbon has no set minimum area, but as a rough guide, projects tend to make financial sense from around 500 hectares. Smaller areas can still work, depending on costs and how much carbon could be built.
Why it matters: if the land doesn't qualify, there's no point going further.
What would I have to do differently?
Carbon projects only reward new changes in how you manage the land, such as changing your grazing, renovating pastures, adding legumes or planting trees. Practices you already use don't count.
Why it matters: the change has to make sense for your farm in its own right, not just for carbon. If it doesn't fit how you want to run your business, it's probably not worth it.
What factors determine if my farm is suitable?
Some of these are outside your control, but they all make a big difference:
-
Size: How much land could go into a project. Some costs are fixed, so bigger areas usually make the numbers easier.
-
Rainfall: Soil carbon projects are generally more reliable where rainfall is above 500 mm a year. For plantings, rainfall and soil drive how fast trees grow, and impacts how many credits they earn.
-
Soil type (soil carbon): Clay soils can hold more carbon than sandy soils. Different soil types across your farm will store different amounts, so some paddocks may have higher potential than others. There's no minimum clay content to qualify, but very sandy soils (under about 8% clay) are rated low feasibility in our assessments.
-
Room to improve (soil carbon): If your soil already holds close to what it can, there's less to gain. The biggest increases usually come from a significant change in management, such as converting cropping land to permanent pasture, rather than small tweaks to what you already do.
-
Records: You'll need a clear picture of how the land has been managed in the past.
-
The right to do it: You need the legal right to run the project, and others with an interest in the land, such as your bank, may need to agree.
Why it matters: these factors largely decide how much carbon you could realistically build, how confident anyone can be about it, and whether a project is practical to run.
Will it pay?
This is about the money: how many credits you could realistically earn, compared with what it would cost to run the project, including sampling, advice, audits, fencing or planting.
Why it matters: even a project that works on paper isn't worth doing if the costs outweigh the returns.
A feasibility tells you whether a project could work and pay its way. Whether it's the right decision for you depends on your plans, your family and your appetite for risk (we will explore this topic in more depth in Part 3).
Feasibility: from broad to detailed assessments in stages
Most feasibility work moves from broad to detailed assessments, with stop/go points at every stage:
-
Desktop screening. A quick, low-cost look using maps, satellite data and climate records to tell you whether it's worth looking further.
-
Detailed desktop assessment. Takes a closer look at specific paddocks, project types and likely credit yields.
-
On-ground checks. Detailed soil sampling, site visits and costings to confirm the accuracy of the stage 2 desktop work.
Sam Duncan from GXLab described the first stage as being like a Fitbit; a useful snapshot of your farm's health, but not as detailed as a blood test. Soil sampling is the blood test, and that comes later.
Looking at feasibility with our Low carbon landscapes project participants
Through the Riverine Plains Low carbon landscapes project, 18 farmers from southern NSW are being supported to progress their carbon-abatement ideas and designs, with every farm in the project receiving a free Environmental Farm Assessment (EFA) from GXLab (formerly FarmLab).
The EFA is a desktop screening tool, covering stage 1 above, and it looked at the feasibility of both soil carbon and environmental planting projects using data for each farm's actual boundary, rather than a district average.
Why we chose GXLab
Riverine Plains engaged GXLab to deliver the assessments because we wanted a screening tool grounded in real soil data, not guesswork.
The GXLAB soil carbon model was trained on more than 5,000 soil carbon measurements (0–30 cm) collected across Australia, including through the federally funded National Soil Carbon Innovation Challenge. GXLab describes the result as Australia's highest-resolution soil carbon map.
Estimates are mapped down to 10-metre cells across each property, so they follow the land rather than a single district number.
Rainfall comes from 20 years of the long-term SILO climate record. The link between clay and achievable soil carbon draws on University of Sydney research. Tree cover comes from the Australian Government's woody vegetation mapping, and planting estimates were developed with Renovo Agriculture.
GXLab has worked on soil carbon measurement since 2018 and is honest about its limits. The model supports planning decisions and it doesn't replace soil sampling or project registration.
What's in the report?
Each EFA included a project summary and four maps providing indicative results for:
-
Soil organic carbon: how much carbon is already in topsoil, across the whole property.
-
Environmental plantings: an estimate of how many carbon credits a planting could earn per hectare, per year, across the property.
-
Tree cover: what's already vegetated, split into woody (20% or more canopy cover) and sparse (under 20%), versus open ground, and what share of your farm falls into each. Vegetated areas can't be used for new plantings.
-
Soil carbon potential: the gap between your current soil carbon and what your soil's clay content and average annual rainfall suggest it could hold. The bigger the gap, the more room to build.
It also included a traffic-light feasibility rating based on three things: farm size, rainfall and average clay content.
-
High: all three are strong (500 ha or more, 500 mm or more of rainfall, and 20% or more clay).
-
Low: any one falls below the minimum (under 100 ha, under 350 mm of rainfall, or under 8% clay).
-
Medium: everything in between.
A "low" or "medium" rating doesn't rule a farm out. It flags where the economics may be harder, so the next conversation can focus on whether the numbers still work.
The report also included an estimate of potential carbon credits over a 25-year project, a 20-year rainfall chart for your location, and suggested next steps, such as baseline soil sampling to confirm the modelled results. Keep in mind that any dollar value depends on ACCU prices, which change over time. No one can predict what they'll be when you come to sell. See an example EFA report.
What's in it for you, even without a carbon project?
Even if a carbon project doesn't eventuate, a desktop assessment can deliver:
-
A whole-farm picture of where your soil carbon is high and low. Differences between paddocks often reflect past management, which can be useful in itself.
-
A view of where plantings would earn the most credits, which is handy when planning shelterbelts or using poorer-performing areas.
-
A starting point for soil sampling; the maps help divide the farm into zones with similar soils, and some early sampling can confirm those zones before the formal baseline.
-
Baseline information that can support conversations with buyers, lenders or other environmental programs.
Following the stage 1 assessments, the Low carbon landscapes project team, Ed Scott (Field Systems), Sayra Samudio and Kate Coffey (Riverine Plains) and Emily Wilson (Murray Local Land Services), have been working with farmers to identify which areas and project types might be suitable, and whether the numbers work for each farm. This has included farm visits to assess potential areas for environmental plantings, and Ed working with GXLab to plan soil sampling zones (stages 2 and 3).
Other ways to get a feasibility assessment
You don't have to be part of our project to explore your carbon project feasibility options. Here are some places to start:
Local Land Services and Landcare groups
Many have staff who specialise in environmental markets and can point you to programs, advice and local examples. Local Land Services has Natural Capital Advisors across NSW who offer tailored advice.
Online tools
-
GXLab: the provider behind our Environmental Farm Assessments. Its platform is used by landholders, consultants and project developers to map farms and manage soil sampling and carbon project data.
-
LOOC-C (CSIRO): helps you explore which carbon project types might suit specific paddocks and estimates potential ACCUs.
-
Nature Layer: offers a free initial desktop screening of carbon farming potential, with paid detailed assessments and on-ground feasibility available.
-
PLANR (Australian Government): a national platform being developed with tools to plan carbon and biodiversity projects.
- BCT Fixed Price Offer: annual payments for protecting native vegetation through a long-term conservation agreement, for eligible properties.
- Credits Near Me: shows whether there's demand for biodiversity credits near your property.
Environmental consultants and carbon service providers
Environmental consultants and carbon service providers can provide detailed feasibility work, usually as a paid service or as part of a project agreement. Before engaging anyone, start with these questions:
-
Is the data based on my farm, or regional averages?
-
Is the feasibility indicative, or based on measurements from my property?
-
Does the feasibility look at both soil carbon and plantings?
-
Does it include costs, not just potential income?
-
Who owns my data, and am I under any obligation afterwards?
Before you engage a provider, also work through the Local Land Services checklist Questions to ask a carbon service provider. It covers project ownership, costs and income, services, risks and legal considerations. The Carbon Market Institute also has guidance for landholders, and a Code of Conduct that providers can sign up to.
What a feasibility assessment can't tell you
A feasibility assessment won't guarantee results. Soil carbon depends on management, seasons and time, and trees can be hard to establish. It also can't decide whether a 25 or 100-year commitment fits your family's plans. That conversation is yours to have, though we're here to support it.
What's next?
If your feasibility shows promise, the next question is whether a carbon project is right for you and your business. That's the topic of Part 3: Is a carbon project right for me?
Questions? Contact Kate Coffey, Head of Farmer Engagement at kate@riverineplains.org.au
This guide provides general information only and is not financial or legal advice. Always seek independent advice for your situation.
Acknowledgement
This project is proudly funded by the NSW Government through a Low Carbon Landscapes grant, delivered under the Primary Industries Productivity and Abatement Program within the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water.
Author
NEWS
Keep up to date with what's happening across the Riverine Plains.
-
Sustainability
-
Grains
